Discovering Pizza Secret & Cocktail Bar in Brooklyn
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn at 72 5th Ave, Pizza Secret & Cocktail Bar stands as a testament to the art of culinary craftsmanship and relaxed social gathering. This establishment has become a notable destination for those who appreciate the intersection of traditional pizza-making techniques and the sophisticated world of mixology. By focusing on a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality ingredients, the venue offers a unique space where locals and visitors alike can unwind after a long day or celebrate special moments in a setting that feels both intimate and energetic.
The philosophy behind the restaurant is rooted in the belief that great food and thoughtful drinks should be accessible, high-quality, and served in an environment that encourages genuine connection. Whether you are a resident of the neighborhood or simply exploring the diverse culinary landscape of New York City, the doors at 72 5th Ave are open to provide a memorable experience that balances the rustic charm of a classic pizzeria with the refined touch of a modern cocktail lounge.
What Makes Our Experience Unique
Artisanal Pizza Craftsmanship: We prioritize the integrity of our dough and the freshness of our toppings. Every pizza is prepared with careful attention to detail, ensuring a perfect balance of texture and flavor that honors the heritage of the dish while embracing contemporary culinary standards.
Curated Cocktail Selection: Our bar program is designed to complement the savory profiles of our menu. We focus on a selection of spirits and ingredients that allow our bartenders to create balanced, nuanced drinks that range from timeless classics to creative, house-inspired concoctions.
Atmosphere and Community: Located in the bustling Brooklyn area, our space is designed to be a comfortable retreat. We believe that the environment is just as important as the meal, which is why we have cultivated a warm, inviting interior that serves as a perfect backdrop for conversations and shared experiences.
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We source our components with intention, working to ensure that every element—from the flour used in our crust to the garnishes in our cocktails—meets a high standard of quality. This dedication to sourcing is the foundation of the flavors we serve every day.
A Destination for Every Occasion
Pizza Secret & Cocktail Bar is more than just a place to eat; it is a space dedicated to the enjoyment of good company and excellent flavors. We understand that the modern diner seeks a balance between casual comfort and culinary excellence, and we strive to provide exactly that. By maintaining a focus on consistent quality and a friendly, professional service style, we aim to be a reliable staple for the Brooklyn community.
We invite you to visit us at 72 5th Ave to experience our approach to hospitality firsthand. Whether you are stopping by for a quick bite, meeting friends for a round of drinks, or looking for a relaxed spot to spend an evening, our team is ready to welcome you. We believe that the best memories are made around a table filled with great food and even better company, and we look forward to being a part of your next Brooklyn experience.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Fireplace
Great wine list
Serves local specialty
Sports
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Braille menu
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Salad bar
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free street parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Menus
Photos
Reviews Pizza Secret & Cocktail Bar
Carl S
23-04-2026
One of the best pizza we’ve ever tried. The pasta and drinks is so good. Thanks to Gab and Coleen for making a dining experience way better. More
Javier Kohen
23-04-2026
Excellent Neapolitan pizza in NYC. The crust was the right amount of chewy, the toppings in the pistachio and burrata pizza were generous and delicious. The montanara pizza with fried dough was lighter than expected and a new and unique … More
Vinny DiBartolo
23-04-2026
This place is at the top of my list. The pizza here is unbelievable. The service is just as good, and you could always trust having good dinner or lunch at this place. I have probably recommended quite a few people here myself, and … More
Lehr Wiener
23-04-2026
1000% recommend this place for everyone for any occasion. Any human never likes everything but this place really sold me and my bf. The service was amazing. The owner, waitress and waiters were great! AND THE FOOD… THE FOOD is outstanding. We are born and raised New Yorkers and this pizza hits all the marks. More
David Q (davqh)
23-04-2026
I actually learned about this restaurant from an Italian show that my Italian teacher mention to me. I absolutely love this place. the food was amazing. The fried calamari tasted fresh. What i love about fried calamari is that it had the … More
Daniel Varrella
23-04-2026
Pizza Secret is absolutely amazing ,best service, best food, and the best atmosphere. Incredible pizza, outstanding staff, and a great vibe that makes you want to stay longer. You can really feel the passion behind everything they do. Highly recommended, I’ll definitely be back! More
Jayson Burton
23-04-2026
An absolute movie! Brought my son here for his bday and the whole restaurant serenaded him. The patrons, the wait staff all sang Dean Martin classics. Oh the food… from the Marguerite pizza to the plated pasta dishes, everything was flavor … More
Murat Zeybeker
23-04-2026
We started with fried mussels, but unfortunately they were clearly not fresh — they tasted rubbery and seemed frozen. The dish also came with calamari, which had the same issue: definitely frozen and far from fresh. … More
Amy Lynn
23-04-2026
Service was fast during Sunday night dinner time-around 6pm. It got busy soon after my party arrived due to Barclays Center event just ending. I ordered the margarita pizza and mushroom pizza. Both tasted amazing…but were a bit soggy in the … More
Mundi S
23-04-2026
One of the best pizzas! The dough is amazing and the balance between the ingredients is perfecto.
Very Neapolitan style and decor. … More
Aleh Ranchynski
23-04-2026
Pizza Secret delivers an authentic Neapolitan experience with charm and warmth. The bright yellow exterior draws you in, but it’s the wood-fired oven and skilled, friendly staff that make the visit memorable. Inside, the space is cozy and … More
dave I
23-04-2026
1/9/26 back for dinner with the guys.
We had a margarita pizza for the table, asked to have it crispy, it was not done crispy! Thin and wet, not great. … More
Krystalye Legario
23-04-2026
Me and my friends were craving for this pizza for a very long time and finally we had a time to hang out and eat here! The best pizza in NYC! Got the espresso martini by coleen and it was the best as ever❤️. The atmosphere and the ambience … More
Joanni Rodriguez
23-04-2026
Pizza Secret has really good food with a great team. Everyone was happy to see us and treated us well. We had cacio e Pepe pizza which we devoured. Cacio e Pepe pasta and a different pasta which I didnt try. We all enjoyed everything we … More
Kami
23-04-2026
We stopped by for lunch with my partner and tried the Vesuvio pizza and a special artichoke cream pizza. Both were cooked perfectly by Francesco, the pizzaiolo, and tasted amazing. … More
Aleks Brzezinski
23-04-2026
This restaurant is of the best in NYC. Try the pizza and pasta you will be blown away. We tried the buffalo, americano, and truffle pizza and the cacio Pepe pasta, perfect. Delicious!! If I could give more stars I would. 5+ out of 5. Thank you to the excellent staff. Limoncello for a perfect end to the meal. More
Christian Hoehner
23-04-2026
After a full day of exploring Brooklyn on foot we crashed here for a late lunch. The welcoming staff and service couldn’t have been friendlier or better. Fun atmosphere with plenty of breeze inside. Salad was crisp/fresh and the pizza was … More
Roberto Luca
23-04-2026
Delicious pizza, light dough, tasty, quality ingredients. Quiet atmosphere, friendly and helpful staff. Excellent Neapolitan pizza. Espresso coffee very good, true Italian Thank you... More
PR Cindy
23-04-2026
This place was ranked the 16th in the US in 2025 and has consistently dominated the top 20 for the past 3 years, winning multiple national and international pizzeria awards! 🏆🇮🇹 The PIZZA magic! 🔥❤️ … More
Chase
23-04-2026
Good pizza with a little twist to it — not your usual NYC slice/pie (think more neopolitan style- wood-fired). Flavors were solid and it felt different in a good way. Worth checking out if you’re nearby or want something a bit outside the … More
Reviews Pizza Secret & Cocktail Bar